Jordan Peterson: 12 Rules For Life, Overture, Rule 1, and Rule 2. Pages: xxv - xxxv and 1 - 64 Instigator: John

A few ground rules.

Per the previously posted schedule, I will put an entry out here for that session of discussion. Then by the specified date the instigator should put his thoughts out there as a comment to the entry. (This is the first entry.)

Etiquette:
We have some diverse opinions in our group. It is important to be respectful of all perspectives. Obviously no personal attacks. It is great to give differing views just be respectful in presentation. Remember on-line statements may sound more harsh than in person. So, bear that in mind. Rather than saying "I think you are wrong" in response you may want to say something like "you make an interesting point. However, I look at it this way..." Definitely you should not say something like "anyone who thinks that way should die a thousand deaths." or something like that. Finally, one the reverse side of things also remember that on line communication can sound harsher than intended. So please take any responses in the most positive light.

Schedule of Instigation - 12 Rules for Life

Hopefully the schedule below is self explanatory. (I will change it if someone drops out.)



Please Note:  The time between instigations is usually 2 weeks.  However.  For longer sections it is 3 weeks.  Sooooo, pay attention.

Instigator: John
Pages: xxv - xxxv
Pages: 1 - 64
Sections: Overture, Rule 1, Rule 2.
Instigation Deadline: EOD - 11/25/18
Response Deadline: EOD - 11/27/18

Instigator: Verna
Pages: 67- 111
Sections: Rule 3, Rule 4
Instigation Deadline: EOD - 12/09/18
Response Deadline: EOD - 12/11/18

Instigator: Thomas
Pages: 113 - 159
Sections: Rule 5, Rule 6
Instigation Deadline: EOD - 1/6/19
Response Deadline: EOD - 1/8/19

Instigator: Jon
Pages: 161 - 230
Sections: Rule 7, Rule 8
Instigation Deadline: EOD - 1/20/19
Response Deadline: EOD - 1/22/19

Instigator: Brian
Pages: 233 - 283
Sections: Rule 9, Rule 10.
Instigation Deadline: EOD - 2/3/19
Response Deadline: EOD - 2/5/19

Instigator: Eric
Pages: 285 - 332
Sections: Rule 11
Instigation Deadline: EOD - 2/17/19
Response Deadline: EOD - 2/19/19

Instigator: Isabelle
Pages: 335 - 368
Sections: Rule 12, Coda
Instigation Deadline: EOD - 3/3/09
Response Deadline: EOD - 3/5/09

Cyber Book Club Take 2

Verna, Jessica, Anna, Isabelle, Chris, Colby, Steven, Jon, Jon's friend, Eric, Mary, Kiley, Michal, Noah, Andrew, Thomas, Amy, Matt, Christopher, Brian, and... Dad (Gil),
It has been almost ten years since some of us participated in the highly acclaimed cyber book club that was such an internet sensation back when the internet was brand new.

After 10 years I feel enough dust has settled that the world is ready for a second cyber book club event!

The first one was so sensational that we are going to get crazy up in here and quadruple the invitee list.  Whew, makes me a little light headed.  I need a drink of water.


Some of you will remember this format.  We will each take two or three weeks to read part of the book selection indicated in a forthcoming post.  Then we will each take turns kicking off an on-line discussion. For each round of discussion the kicker-offer, let’s call them the instigator, will post their thoughts and then the others will take time to respond to the reading and the instigators thoughts. We’ll have a different instigator for each section of the book designated in the forthcoming post. We will adjust things as needed.

The book we will be reading is –

12 Rules For Life by Jordan Peterson.

Link on Amazon:

https://www.amazon.com/12-Rules-Life-Antidote-Chaos-ebook/dp/B01FPGY5T0/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1540510133&sr=8-1&keywords=12+rules+for+life
 

We will officially start toward the end of November and I will post a schedule for who is to be the instigator when. I’ll call it the Schedule of Instigation.

To get the concept started please post a comment to this post indicating you plan to do this AND whether or not you want to be an instigator or just want to comment on other people's posts. 

I will post a comment as a sample.

Dietrich Bonhoeffer The Cost of Discipleship Final Thoughts

Final Thoughts.

I think we may be suffering from the dreaded malady of Bonhoeffer Fatige, similar to Fibre Myalgia or Plantar Fasciitis. So, lets wrap things up with this post.

Dietrich Bonhoeffer: The Cost of Discipleship The Harvest, The Apostles, The Work, The Suffering of the Messangers, The Decision, The Fruit

Instigator: John
Pages: 201 - 221
Instigation Deadline: EOD - 5/4/09
Response Deadline: EOD - 5/6/09

Dietrich Bonhoeffer The Cost of Dicipleship The Simplicity of the Carefree Life, The Disciple and Unbelievers, The Great Divide, The Conclusion

Instigator: Gil
Pages: 173 - 197
Sections: The Simplicity of the Carefree Life, The Disciple and Unbelievers, The Great Divide, The Conclusion
Instigation Deadline: EOD - 4/20/09
Response Deadline: EOD - 4/22/09

Dietrich Bonhoeffer The Cost of Dicipleship Sections: Revenge, The Enemy - the "Extraordinary", The Hidden Righteousness, The Hiddenness of Prayer

Instigator: Matt
Pages: 140 - 172
Sections: Revenge, The Enemy - the "Extraordinary", The Hidden Righteousness, The Hiddenness of Prayer, The Hiddenness of the Devout Life.
Instigation Deadline: EOD - 3/23/09
Response Deadline: EOD - 3/25/09

Dietrich Bonhoeffer The Cost of Discipleship The Beatitudes, The Righteousness of Christ, The Brother, Women, Truthfuln 105 - 139 Instigator: Eric

Instigator: Eric
Pages: 105 - 139
Sections: The Beatitudes, The Righteousness of Christ, The Brother, Women, Truthfulness
Instigation Deadline: EOD - 3/9/09
Response Deadline: EOD - 3/11/09

Dietrich Bonhoeffer The Cost of Discipleship Single Minded Obedience, Discipleship and the Cross 79 - 101 Instigator: Thomas

Thomas - You are up to bat.
Pages: 79 - 101
Sections: Single Minded Obedience, Discipleship and the Cross

Please instigate by posting a comment to this.

Dietrich Bonhoeffer: The Cost of Discipleship Costly Grace, The Call to Discipleship 43 - 78 Instigator: Jon

Sections: Costly Grace, The Call to Discipleship

Jon, your up. Please instigate by commenting on this post.

The Cost of Discipleship Cover to page 39 Instigator: John

Okay, a few ground rules.

Every two weeks I will put an entry out here for that session of discussion. Then by the specified date the instigator should put his thoughts out there as a comment to the entry. (This is the first entry.)

Etiquette:
We have some diverse opinions in our group. It is important to be respectful of all perspectives. Obviously no personal attacks. It is great to give differing views just be respectful in presentation. Remember on-line statements may sound more harsh than in person. So, bear that in mind. Rather than saying "I think you are wrong" in response you may want to say something like "you make an interesting point. However, I look at it this way." Definitely you should not say something like "anyone who thinks that way should die a thousand deaths." or something like that. Finally, one the reverse side of things also remember that on line communication can sound harsher than intended. So please take any responses in the most positive light.

Schedule of Instigation

Hopefully the schedule below is self explanitory. (I will change it if someone drops out.)

Instigator: John
Pages: 0 - 42
Sections: Cover, Also Available from Simon & Schuster, Various Notes on the Publication, Table of Contents, Memoir, Introduction.
Instigation Deadline: EOD - 1/19/09
Response Deadline: EOD - 1/21/09

Instigator: Jon
Pages: 43- 78
Sections: Costly Grace, The Call to Discipleship
Instigation Deadline: EOD - 2/2/09
Response Deadline: EOD - 2/4/09

Instigator: Thomas
Pages: 79 - 101
Sections: Single Minded Obedience, Discipleship and the Cross
Instigation Deadline: EOD - 2/16/09
Response Deadline: EOD - 2/18/09

Instigator: Eric
Pages: 105 - 139
Sections: The Beatitudes, The Righteousness of Christ, The Brother, Women, Truthfulness
Instigation Deadline: EOD - 3/9/09
Response Deadline: EOD - 3/11/09

Instigator: Matt
Pages: 140 - 172
Sections: Revenge, The Enemy - the "Extraordinary", The Hidden Righteousness, The Hiddenness of Prayer, The Hiddenness of the Devout Life.
Instigation Deadline: EOD - 3/23/09
Response Deadline: EOD - 3/25/09

Instigator: Gil
Pages: 173 - 197
Sections: The Simplicity of the Carefree Life, The Disciple and Unbelievers, The Great Divide, The Conclusion
Instigation Deadline: EOD - 4/20/09
Response Deadline: EOD - 4/22/09

Instigator: John
Pages: 201 - 221
Sections: The Harvest, The Apostles, The Work, The Suffering of the Messangers, The Decision, The Fruit
Instigation Deadline: EOD - 5/4/09
Response Deadline: EOD - 5/6/09

Instigator: Thomas
Pages: 223 - 247
Sections: Preliminary Questions, Baptism, The Body of Christ,
Instigation Deadline: EOD - 5/18/09
Response Deadline: EOD - 5/20/09

Instigator: Eric
Pages: 248 - 271
Sections: The Visible Community
Instigation Deadline: EOD - 6/3/09
Response Deadline: EOD - 6/5/09

Instigator: Gil
Pages: 272 - 317
Sections: The Saints, The Image of Christ, Index of Subjects, Index of Biblical References, Other Books by Bonhoeffer.
Instigation Deadline: EOD - 6/17/09
Response Deadline: EOD - 6/19/09

Book Club

Jon, Eric, Thomas, Matt, Dad (Gil),

You are invited (commanded) to participate in a cyber book club. (When you say that really emphasize the word “cyber.” Make it loud with a little vibrato and maybe try to simulate an echo effect.) The book club will work like this. We will each take a couple weeks to read part of the book selection revealed below and then we will each take turns kicking off an on-line discussion. For each round of discussion the kicker-offer, let’s call them the instigator, will post their thoughts and the others will take time to respond to the reading and the instigators thoughts. We’ll have a different instigator every two weeks with a specific passage to cover. We will adjust things as needed as we see how things go.

There will be no tea and scones.

A message to the hundreds and thousands of other people who visit this blog every hour. Please, don’t feel left out. Even if you are not on the schedule as an instigator you are invited to contribute as long as you keep it civil and clean. And please don’t visit the blog more than 5 or 6 times a day. We don’t want to bring the server down.

The book we will be reading is –rumpupumpumpumpumpumpum- (That’s a drum roll sort of like from the little drummer boy.)

The Cost of Discipleship by Dietrich Bonhoeffer.

Link on Amazon:

http://www.amazon.com/Cost-Discipleship-Dietrich-Bonhoeffer/dp/0684815001/ref=pd_bbs_2?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1229392552&sr=8-2

We will officially start after the first of the year and I will post a schedule for who is to be the instigator when. I’ll call it the Schedule of Instigation.

Just to get the concept started please post a comment indicating you plan to do this. I suggest something like, “I’m in.” Make it cool like they might do it on Ocean’s Eleven or the Gum Ball Rally.

I will post a comment as a sample.

And no. I’m sorry. No scones or tea.

Population Density

There is a lot of discussion these days regarding resource utilization by the human race and sustainable consumption. Jared Diamond wrote a book related to this called Collapse in which he explores the reasons some societies succeed and others fail. Reading this made me think about how many people could be sustained on earth on an on going basis and not exhaust our resources.

To start with let me say I have no idea. Also, there are a lot of factors which should be dealt with to make an accurate prediction of a sustainable world population level for humans and I’m not sure such a thing is even possible. But out of curiosity I thought it would be interesting to compare some population levels just to get a feel for whether or not there is any hope for us at current population levels.

First let’s look at Easter Island. It’s a tiny Island in the South Pacific about 63 square miles in area and 100s of miles from anything else except water. To put that in context that’s about twice as large as Manhattan. This is the Island where the funky statues where built that are featured in movies and cartoons that have scenes on remote tropical islands. At one point Easter Island supported a relatively successful society that was able to be productive and innovative enough to produce big funky statues. Eventually they chopped down all their trees (primary natural resource) and their society and population collapsed. Some folks estimate that the high water mark for Easter Island population was around 20,000. (I think others think it could have been higher.) That’s a population density of 122 people per km2. So, 122 people per km2 might be too many to sustain; at least on a small island with limited access to resources not immediately on the island. (Note the parallel between Easter Island and Earth in general.)

Next let’s look at Haiti. This is another island nation one could argue has failed as a society. It is not as remote or small as Easter Island. It has a population of around 9 million and about 316 people per km2. So, I guess 316 people per km2 is too many to sustain.

Interestingly the UK, yet another Island nation only with several hundred years of relative success, has about 256 km2. Hmm. Maybe the world could support this level of population density. Of course one might argue that part of the reason that the UK can support that level of population is because they use a lot of resources from other locals. For the world, we have not figured out a means of harvesting resources out side of our “little” ball. So we may not want to just assume the 256 km2 is a sustainable population level.

Now for the United States. The United States has about 33 people per km2. Much lower than any of the other societies noted and even though the U. S. is highly integrated with the World economy as is United Kingdom and we have a lot of issues we seem to be humming along pretty well and it would seem that we could sustain our society for some time as long as we solved some problems like securing sustainable fuel sources and global warming and fixing unsustainable entitlement programs like Social Security in its current form. So, our world might not be able to sustain 100, 200, or 300 plus people per km2. But maybe 33 people per km2 is doable.

Finally, the whole world has about 45 people per km2. Now this is a ridiculously simplistic analysis if it can even be considered analysis but the conclusion I draw from this is that our current population is not at such a level that we are destined to a major failure. If it where above like 100 km2 then I think you could say we are definitely in trouble. But our current population might be manageable. We probably don’t want to have it grow a whole lot and we do have big problems to solve but there is still hope that the world population can survive and thrive at current levels.

http://www.apj.co.uk/rapanui/display_article.asp?specifier=history

https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/ha.html

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jasper_County,_Iowa

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manhattan

https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/us.html

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_population_density

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Easter_Island

Thoughts on Peter Singer's Book

“Writings on an Ethical Life” is an anthology of excerpts, essays, and articles by Peter Singer on a variety of ethical questions. I don’t recommend this book as I fundamentally disagree with many of the basic assumptions and conclusions of Dr. Singer. However, I must say that he clearly states his assumptions and then explores the implications of these with incredible intellectual integrity. My next few posts will be some truly half baked reflections on my reading of this book.

The first thing I want to say is very weak on my part because I remember reading this but I couldn’t actually find it anywhere in the highlights I made in the book when I read it. I don’t want to reread it. So, I’m going to have to depend on memory. Somewhere in there he discussed the impact of one’s belief in evolution verses creation. He indicated that one’s belief in either of these will likely significantly impact one’s ethical views. I think this is a really good point. However, he went on to say that as far as he knows all truly intellectual individuals that are affiliated with our academic institutions don’t believe in creation. They believe in evolution and because of this he did not feel the need to address the implications a creationist view has on ethics. This is the one area where I felt he lacked integrity. Basically he is saying that because the people in his club, the academic crowd, don’t believe in creation it is not a legitimate point of view with out taking the time to defend that position.

As someone who believes in creation, this, I feel, is one of the fundamental flaws in his system of ethics.